It’s no secret that the Marvel Cinematic Universe has been struggling for a while. There’s been a few hits here and there since Avengers: Endgame, but overall, the quality has been lacking. A new Spider-Man movie is almost always a safe bet to turn things around. So, the question is, does Spider-Man: Brand New Day provide the spark that Marvel Studios needs to build momentum towards the upcoming Avengers: Doomsday? Luckily for them, it does.
Spider-Man: Brand New Day, directed by Destin Daniel Cretton, is probably the most personal and introspective Spider-Man movie since Sam Raimi’s Spider-Man 2. Set four years after the events of Spider-Man: No Way Home, Peter is a bit of a lost cause. No one remembers him and he has no social life. The only thing that fulfills him is being Spider-Man and fighting crime in New York City. But there’s limits to that, and eventually all the pressure and responsibility start to affect him physically in unexpected ways. At the same time, a new threat emerges that is unlike anything he has encountered before.

Where Brand New Day truly shines is how grounded and personal it is. It’s got the usual big set pieces you would expect from a Spider-Man movie, but at its heart it’s a tale about loneliness, isolation, and how it’s okay to ask for help. This gives the film some emotional depth to an extent not seen in a Spider-Man movie since Spider-Man 2. While I don’t think it reaches the height of that film (not many superhero movies do), it feels refreshing to get a more grounded and personal superhero movie that deals with some timely themes.
Performances usually aren’t a noteworthy thing to point out when discussing superhero movies, but there’s a rare exception here. Tom Holland gives one of his best performances as a vulnerable Peter Parker/Spider-Man. He really sells a broken Peter Parker trying to find his place in the world. Jon Bernthal also shines as Frank Castle/The Punisher, giving one of his best performances as well as displaying good chemistry with Holland. The rest of the cast, notably Sadie Sink and Zendaya, also do a solid job in their roles.

Where I think Brand New Day stumbles a bit is that I think it has too many characters, and some characters are thrown in for the sake of being there. For example, from the trailers, it looked like Scorpion and The Hand were going to play big roles in the movie, but they ended up not being much of a factor. The movie would have been the same without them. Without going into spoilers, there’s also the fact that Sadie Sink’s character steals a bit too much of the focus away from Spider-Man. It sort of feels like Marvel was trying to introduce and set her character up for the future while also telling a Spider-Man story. It works to an extent, but the film still could have been more focused.

Overall, Spider-Man: Brand New Day is a bit of a rarity: a superhero movie with a brain and heart, despite its tendency to feel overstuffed. While it is very much a fun summer popcorn flick, it’s also a thoughtful examination of loneliness and the effects it can have on someone. Combine that with heartfelt performances and thrilling action, and the result is a real treat. Hopefully Marvel Studios can continue this momentum with Avengers: Doomsday at the end of the year.
Rating: 4/5



